An old arrest or conviction shouldn’t follow you forever. D.C. law now makes it possible to seal many convictions—not just arrests.
D.C.’s Second Chance Amendment Act of 2022 rewrote the District’s record-sealing law. For the first time, many people with criminal convictions—not only arrests or dismissed charges—can ask the Superior Court to seal their records.
Even an old record can close doors to jobs, housing, professional opportunities, and peace of mind. For people who have moved forward with their lives, sealing can remove that record from public view.
Convictions can now be sealed
Eligible misdemeanor and felony convictions may be sealed by motion.
Some records seal automatically
Certain records are scheduled to be sealed or expunged without a motion.
Relief applies retroactively
The law applies to older cases, not just new ones.
A real legal standard
Motions are decided under an “interests of justice” test.
Some records will be sealed automatically. But the courts have until October 1, 2027 to complete that process, and many records never qualify.
Cases that ended without a conviction
Arrests and charges that were dropped or otherwise ended without a conviction are generally scheduled for automatic sealing.
Misdemeanor convictions after 10 years
Many misdemeanor convictions are scheduled for automatic sealing once 10 years have passed since the sentence was completed.
Decriminalized offenses
Records for offenses later decriminalized, legalized, or held unconstitutional—and simple marijuana possession before February 15, 2015—are slated for automatic expungement.
Not everything seals automatically
Many offenses are excluded from automatic sealing—including intrafamily offenses, crimes of violence, dangerous crimes, DUI and impaired-driving offenses, and certain sex offenses. Those records can only be sealed by motion, if at all. And if your record qualifies for sealing by motion now, you don’t have to wait for the automatic process.
A motion to seal can reach records that the automatic process won’t—or won’t reach for years. Eligibility depends on the outcome of the case, the offense, and how much time has passed since the sentence was completed.
No conviction
Arrests and charges that were dismissed or otherwise ended without a conviction—including completed DSAs and DPAs. No waiting period.
Misdemeanor convictions
Eligible after at least 5 years from completion of the sentence.
Felony convictions
Eligible after at least 8 years from completion of the sentence. The most serious felony categories are not eligible.
Fugitive-from-justice arrests
Certain D.C. arrests on out-of-state fugitive warrants, once the underlying matter has been addressed.
Many first-time offenders in D.C. Superior Court resolve their cases through a deferred prosecution or deferred sentencing agreement. When the case is dismissed, it is not a conviction.
Deferred Sentencing Agreement (DSA)
You enter a guilty plea, complete the conditions set by the court, and return to court. You may then withdraw the plea, and the government dismisses the case.
Deferred Prosecution Agreement (DPA)
No guilty plea is entered. You complete the agreed conditions, and the case is dismissed.
Because the case ended in a dismissal, there is no waiting period to file a motion to seal. Many of these records will eventually be sealed automatically, but a motion can get you there sooner. For certain offenses, a motion is the only way.
Unpaid fines don’t stop the clock
Unpaid fines, restitution, or other court costs do not prevent a sentence from being considered complete for purposes of the waiting period.
You choose what to seal
You don’t have to seek relief for every record at once, or meet the waiting period for every case on your record.
The court grants a motion to seal when the person shows, by a preponderance of the evidence, that sealing is in the interests of justice. The judge weighs your interest in sealing and the community’s interest in your rehabilitation—through education, employment, and housing—against the community’s interest in access to the record.
If a motion is denied, the court generally won’t consider another for a year—and only three motions are allowed. It pays to get it right the first time.
The court may consider:
How Carrie handles a sealing motion:
Review the full record
A motion must list every unsealed arrest, charge, and conviction. Carrie starts by building a complete picture.
Confirm eligibility & timing
She identifies which records qualify now, which qualify later, and the right strategy for each.
Build a persuasive motion
Facts, exhibits, affidavits, and legal argument showing why sealing serves the interests of justice.
Respond & argue
If the prosecutor opposes or the court sets a hearing, Carrie responds and presents your case.
The court must rule in writing, generally within 180 days of filing. If the motion is granted, the records are to be sealed within 90 days.
Expungement is broader than sealing. It restores a person, in the eyes of the law, to where they stood before the arrest.
When a case ended without a conviction, a person may move to expunge the records by showing, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the offense did not occur or was not committed by them. The motion may be filed at any time.
If the court grants it, the order states as a matter of law that the person did not commit the offense or that no offense occurred. A dismissal or acquittal alone does not establish innocence, so these motions require careful factual development and legal argument.
Sealing does
Sealing doesn’t
Related: Maryland Expungement & Shielding · Post-Conviction Relief & Appeals · Criminal Immigration Consequences
A motion to seal is your story, told persuasively.
Compassionate.
The person you are today matters.
Carrie learns your story, your work, your family, and how you’ve moved forward, because that’s what persuades a judge.
Determined.
Built to succeed the first time.
With a one-year wait after a denial and only three motions allowed, she prepares every motion thoroughly: facts, exhibits, affidavits, and legal argument.
Creative.
Every path to a cleaner record.
Sealing now, sealing later, actual-innocence expungement: she maps the right strategy for each record.

Carrie Crumbaugh Love brings 25 years of legal experience and a genuine commitment to the people she represents.
For a motion to seal, that means telling your story persuasively and showing the court who you are today.
Compassion for the person behind the case
Understanding who you are and what’s at stake shapes her determination to pursue every available avenue toward the best possible outcome.
A journalist’s curiosity
A former reporter, Carrie digs into the facts and asks the questions needed to understand the full story.
Creative, innovative solutions
When a situation seems to have no good options, Carrie keeps looking. She thinks outside the box to find solutions tailored to your circumstances.
Trusted by fellow attorneys
Other lawyers regularly refer their clients to Carrie, and you can come to her directly, too.
Recognized among the Top 100 Trial Lawyers in criminal defense, Washington, D.C. (The National Trial Lawyers, 2016) and the Best Criminal Defense Attorneys in Washington, D.C. (Expertise.com, 2022).
Carrie Crumbaugh Love LAW evaluates D.C. record-sealing and expungement matters individually, beginning with a careful review of the full record.
Substantive legal consultations are generally paid. Fee information is provided before scheduling. Please avoid submitting detailed confidential information in an initial inquiry.
This page summarizes D.C. Code §§ 16-801 to 16-809 as of November 2026 for general information. It is not legal advice; eligibility depends on the specific record and circumstances.